Brian Sims
Editor
Brian Sims
Editor
OVERSIGHT AND safeguards for police force use of retrospective facial recognition are not consistent. That’s the headline finding of the 58-page report ‘How Police Forces and the National Crime Agency Use Retrospective Facial Recognition’ issued by His Majesty’s Inspectorate of Constabulary and Fire and Rescue Services (HMICFRS).
HMICFRS has highlighted that, where used appropriately, retrospective facial recognition can be a valuable and proportionate investigative tool. Retrospective facial recognition has reduced the need for widespread and routine sharing of images by the police through traditional media appeals for information. Instead, forces can use retrospective facial recognition to quickly identify potential suspects and missing or deceased people by comparing images from surveillance cameras, dashcams, social media and other sources with existing custody images.
The report adds that policing has taken steps to address concerns about algorithm bias when using retrospective facial recognition, but “more needs to be done” to reduce the risks of people being wrongly arrested.
Further, HMICFRS has warned that governance, consistency and accountability should be improved. Inspectors found that legislation hasn’t kept in step with changes in facial recognition technology, while there’s no comprehensive statutory framework governing this technology’s use. This makes it more somewhat difficult for police forces to understand the lawful basis for retrospective facial recognition’s use and what safeguards are needed to protect members of the public.
The retention of custody images “remains an area of concern”. HMICFRS inspectors found some images which should have been deleted under existing retention rules. Such occurrences “risk undermining public confidence”.
Lawful and proportionate
His Majesty’s Inspector of Constabulary Kathryn Stone said: “The introduction of facial recognition technology has transformed suspect identification. Officers no longer need to compare images manually and can access the results in seconds, thereby helping them to identify suspects more quickly and solve crimes for the public.”
Stone continued: “Our inspection process found that the public generally supports the use of retrospective facial recognition. Continued support will depend on policing showing that it uses this technology lawfully, proportionately and openly.”
Further, Stone noted: “Police forces must be able to show that appropriate safeguards are in place, risks relating to bias and data retention are effectively managed and decisions are still subject to human judgement. A clearer statutory framework, stronger national standards and improved governance and oversight arrangements are essential for maintaining public confidence.”
The Inspectorate also found that investigators didn’t always receive the training and support needed to understand the capabilities and limitations of retrospective facial recognition, with a more consistent national approach needed. Variation in how well investigators understood the processes for using retrospective facial recognition meant that some less experienced investigators didn’t always understand that a potential retrospective facial recognition match must be corroborated through further enquiries.
It emerges that the maturity of governance arrangements also varies considerably between police forces. Some have established policies and safeguards in place, while others rely heavily on limited national guidance, which then increases the risk of inconsistent decision making and misunderstanding in relation to the technology’s limitations.
Series of recommendations
HMICFRS has made 16 recommendations intended to improve how police forces and the National Crime Agency use retrospective facial recognition and maintain public confidence in its use by:
*improving national and local governance arrangements
*introducing clear national standards
*making sure retrospective facial recognition is used more consistently
*introducing clear oversight and supervision of the use of retrospective facial recognition
*improving guidance and training (notably so for investigators)
Read How Police Forces and the National Crime Agency Use Retrospective Facial Recognition
Akiko Hart, director of Liberty, commented: “The growing use of retrospective facial recognition by the police, the lack of understanding of the technology and the possible unlawful retention of custody images is a dangerous combination.”
Hart continued: “Alvi Choudhury’s case has already shown the human cost of these failures when he was removed from his home by the police and detained for ten hours for a burglary in a city he had never visited.”
In addition, Hart noted: “This continued disregard for legal obligations when it comes to privacy and civil liberties, as well as either inadequate or non-existent training on facial recognition, will do little to reassure the public that their rights are being protected.”
According to Hart: “These findings further underline the need for the Government to finally deliver legislation on facial recognition now that the consultation response has been published.”
Western Business Media Limited
Dorset House
64 High Street
East Grinstead
RH19 3DE
UNITED KINGDOM