Brian Sims
Editor
Brian Sims
Editor
THE NATIONAL Resilience Committee in the House of Lords has published a report in which it has found UK emergency planning to be “out of date, underfunded and untested” (with cyber attacks outlined as the lead example of how one failure can spread right across the country).
The National Resilience Committee recommends that the Government should:
*strengthen leadership and accountability for national resilience: appoint a dedicated Cabinet minister responsible solely for resilience, supported by a Chief Resilience Officer at Permanent Secretary level
*establish a single national resilience strategy: set out clear responsibilities, common standards and measurable objectives ensuring that national, regional and local plans work together and are regularly tested
*strengthen local resilience arrangements: establish regional co-ordination centres to connect national decisions with local delivery and place Local Resilience Forums on a statutory footing with clear responsibilities and sustainable funding
*reduce dependence on vulnerable supply chains: strengthen domestic production and strategic reserves of essential supplies, particularly so medicines, food and agricultural inputs and diversify international supply arrangements
*require businesses and critical sectors to strengthen their preparedness: introduce proportionate resilience requirements for businesses, including statutory duties for those essential to national resilience, and regular cross-sector stress testing to identify weaknesses before emergencies occur
*improve the UK’s cyber resilience: widen the scope of cyber security regulation, ensure regulators have sufficient resources and strengthen domestic expertise in cyber security and emerging technologies
*give the public clear information and practical ways to prepare: build on the Government’s ‘Be Ready’ campaign by providing a preparedness booklet to every household, developing a multilingual emergency app and embedding resilience education and skills throughout life
*protect communications during emergencies: establish and regularly test arrangements for back-up communications during major disruption and abandon plans to switch off digital terrestrial television
*demonstrate that the UK is meeting its international resilience commitments: publish performance against NATO’s seven civil preparedness baseline requirements and explain how any gaps will be addressed.
“Seriously underprepared”
The 102-page report notes that the UK is seriously underprepared for major and interconnected threats, while existing plans too often address individual emergencies rather than cascading crises.
Fragmented leadership and co-ordination prevent national resilience plans from being translated consistently into practical action across Government and at the local level.
Limited domestic production and the dependence on vulnerable international supply chains leave essential food, medicine and other supplies exposed to prolonged disruption.
Businesses, voluntary organisations and communities are not yet sufficiently integrated into national and local preparedness, despite their vital role in maintaining essential services.
The Government has not communicated national risks openly or consistently enough. Building a culture of resilience requires practical information and participation across society.
Baroness Coussins, chair of the National Resilience Committee, said: “The world is more turbulent and insecure than it has been for decades. Yet in the face of potentially catastrophic risks, the Government appears complacent and the UK is underprepared. We need urgent action to connect our plans, protect essential services and make preparedness part of everyday life.”
Cyber dimension
Sanjana Mehta, associate vice-president of advocacy at ISACA, commented: “The National Resilience Committee’s report is a timely reminder that the threats facing the UK rarely arrive one at a time. A cyber attack can quickly spread into healthcare, food supply and communications, which means resilience has to be planned across the whole system.”
Mehta continued: “The most important word in this report is ‘untested’. A resilience plan that has never been put under pressure is really just a set of assumptions. The first test shouldn’t be a real crisis.”
Further, Mehta observed: “Most of what the Committee describes, from food distribution to undersea cables, is run by private organisations. As ISACA highlighted in its evidence to the Committee, cyber risks don’t stop at the boundaries of regulated sectors. National resilience depends on whether organisations – including economically significant businesses outside the scope of existing regulation – regularly test their continuity plans, understand how they depend on their suppliers and have Boards of Directors that ask hard questions about what happens when things fail.”
In addition, Mehta noted: “The Committee’s call for clear ministerial ownership of resilience and an annual statement to Parliament reflects the same principle. Accountability matters at the top of Government just as it does in the Boardroom. Regular reporting on preparedness, including cyber resilience, would help to keep it on the agenda.”
In conclusion, Mehta stated: “The Cyber Security and Resilience Bill is a golden opportunity to make regular resilience testing and assurance the norm. With the Government committing to requiring Boards to oversee security frameworks and put skilled and accredited professionals in charge of cyber resilience, the building blocks are being laid. ISACA has worked with the Government throughout the Bill’s passage through Parliament and we look forward to supporting further as these commitments take shape.”
*Read ‘Are We Ready: Building a Culture of Resilience’ online
Western Business Media Limited
Dorset House
64 High Street
East Grinstead
RH19 3DE
UNITED KINGDOM